topgradeauthors.com-logo.png

Our Services

Get 15% Discount on your First Order

Health & Medical Question

Choose a case where either a legal or ethical decision was made. Use a case in  Vaughn’s  bioethics textbook or another of your choosing. Summarize the case and outcome. Take a stance whether you believe that was the correct outcome/ decision based on relevant ethical principles, concepts and theories. Describe your stance in detail referencing the textbook and or other relevant reliable sources. Typed, double spaced using apa format   

Expert Solution Preview

Title: Ethical Decision-Making in Healthcare: Analysis of a Case

Introduction:
In the realm of medicine, practitioners often encounter challenging situations that require them to make crucial decisions with legal or ethical implications. This discussion delves into the analysis of a case involving a legal or ethical decision, offering an evaluation of the outcome based on relevant ethical principles, concepts, and theories. By drawing upon Vaughn’s bioethics textbook and other reliable sources, an informed stance will be taken to assess the correctness of the decision made in light of the case.

Case Summary:
The selected case involves the “Baby Doe” case, which gained significant attention in the early 1980s in the United States. Baby Doe was born with severe esophageal atresia, a condition that affected his ability to swallow and sustain proper nutrition. Without immediate corrective surgery, Baby Doe would likely die within a short period. However, the parents belonging to the religious group known as the Christian Science Church refused medical treatment for the child based on religious beliefs. Consequently, the hospital initiated legal proceedings to authorize the surgery and challenge the parents’ stance.

Outcome:
The court, in their ruling, sided with the hospital and authorized the surgery to be performed on Baby Doe, overriding the parents’ objections. Despite the medical intervention, the child failed to survive due to prolonged malnutrition and associated complications.

Stance and Justification:
Based on relevant ethical principles, concepts, and theories, I believe the outcome of the Baby Doe case was the correct decision. One crucial ethical principle that supports this stance is the Best Interest Principle, which states that healthcare professionals should prioritize the best interests of the patient, especially when their life is at stake (Vaughn, 2016).

In this case, the parents’ religious beliefs conflicted with the welfare of the child. By refusing the necessary surgery, they were placing their faith above their child’s right to life and disregarding the child’s best interest. The court’s decision to authorize the surgery protected the child from potentially avoidable suffering and upheld the principle of beneficence.

Additionally, the ethical principle of Autonomy applies to this case. While it is essential to respect parental autonomy, it should not extend to the extent that it infringes upon the rights and welfare of a child. Given that Baby Doe was unable to exercise autonomy on his own behalf, the court had a duty to act as a voice for the child’s best interest.

Furthermore, the concept of Negligence is relevant here. The hospital had a legal obligation under the principle of Nonmaleficence to ensure that the child received timely and appropriate medical care. By pursuing legal action, the hospital fulfilled this obligation and prevented potential harm from befalling the child.

In conclusion, the outcome of the Baby Doe case, whereby the court authorized the surgery against the parents’ objections, aligns with the principles of beneficence, autonomy, and nonmaleficence. By prioritizing the best interests of the child, protecting their right to life, and preventing potential harm, the decision made was ethically sound and justified.

References:
Vaughn, L. (2016). Bioethics: Principles, Issues, and Cases (3rd ed.). Oxford University Press.

Share This Post

Email
WhatsApp
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Pinterest
Reddit

Order a Similar Paper and get 15% Discount on your First Order

Related Questions

Technology for Patient Safety in Saudi Arabia Paper Nursing Assignment Help

You are the manager of a busy hospital unit.  Your unit has been tasked with selecting and implementing upgraded technology on your hospital unit.  As the unit manger, address the following in your selection of technology and implementation plan: Examine the features of the new technology that are important in

WU Detail and Dynamic Complexity Discussion

Are you overwhelmed by complexity? If so, you are not alone. Peter Senge notes that people are now able to “create far more information that anyone can absorb,” and he continues to say that the “scale of complexity is without precedent” (2006, p. 69). This “detail” complexity can make managing

Pediatric Health & Medical Worksheet Nursing Assignment Help

Provider: i. Questions for HPI When did these symptoms begin? Is the child experience exercise intolerance? Any shortness of breath/signs of respiratory distress? History of genetic conditions? ii. Questions for ROS Poor feeding? Any newborn cardiac concerns? Previous cardiac history? Any pain, weakness, coldness to the extremities? Fluid retention? Cough

Health & Medical Capital Budgeting at Cleveland Clinic Nursing Assignment Help

Respond to each of the following prompts or questions: Using the information provided in the Los Reyes Hospital case study from Module Three, what capital expenditures may the selected departments need to budget? Considering the organization you selected, what is a capital expenditure that may be needed that would result

NVCC Service Implementation and Elements of Financial

Instructions: Part 1 1.Read Chapter 10, Capko. -Critique either Dr. Grainger’s or Mid-South Pulmomary Specialists efforts in developing  new services. -What lessons did you learn as related to new service development?   -List three main items which you must address before implementing a new service.  Instructions: Part 2 -The physicians

Healthcare is reimbursed in a variety of ways. The Nursing Assignment Help

Healthcare is reimbursed in a variety of ways. The prospective payment method is one of those ways. This paper will be about the prospective payment method where diagnosis-related groupings (DRGs) forms the basis for payment. Research and explain the origin, purpose, and description of DRGs. Include what payment is based on.

TOPIC: Maternal mental health in pregnancy and child

                                                                TOPIC: Maternal mental health in pregnancy and child behavior.   Find 3 professional journal articles on your topic of

In this Discussion Board, choose one of the topics below for

In this Discussion Board, choose one of the topics below for your original post. Be certain to address each of the questions for that topic. In responses to your peers make certain you participate in both discussions. Topic 1: The Nursing Shortage How would you define the Nursing Shortage? What

HU Health & Medical Clients Discovery of Negative Impacts

A discussion about one of the videos you watched, either for client Eddie, Ms. Clark, or Leann.  You will find a link for the videos within this week’s folder.  After viewing the video, answer the following questions on a new thread: Name the Stage of Change for this client and

NUR 630 FIU Impact on Healthcare Systems and Public Health

Autism Spectrum Disorder, Intellectual Disabilities, or Childhood-Onset Schizophrenia In recent years, there have been reports linking autism to vaccinations. After studying Module 5: Lecture Materials & Resources, address the following in a well-written discussion post: Explain the controversy regarding vaccines as a possible cause of autism spectrum disorder. Does the